Website CV Paper
Fields
Education, Behavioral & Experimental, Innovation, Applied Micro
Job market paper
Blindsided at the Start: Small Early Shocks and High-Stakes Selection
A central question in institutional design is how formal rules translate into realized economic outcomes. We examine this question in high-stakes selection, distinguishing the first question's formal scoring contribution from its wider influence on performance. Combining administrative records for 13.6 million candidates in China's National College Entrance Examination with GPT-4o-based difficulty measures for 484 mathematics questions from 22 examination sets, we exploit variation in opening difficulty across administratively assigned papers, conditional on measured aggregate difficulty, province and year fixed effects, and individual characteristics. A one-standard-deviation increase in opening difficulty is associated with a 6.4-point decline in mathematics scores. This point estimate exceeds the item's maximum five-point value, suggesting effects beyond its direct scoring contribution. Students from high schools with stronger first-tier university admission records incur smaller losses. When applications are submitted before the examination, this differential extends to relative rank, with suggestive evidence that the STEM university placement gap among admitted students widens by 1.4 percentage points in their favor. Patterns across examination contexts and task content are consistent with expectation-based salience against a familiar easy-start convention, potentially operating through cognitive interference. The findings suggest that individual responses can give a component with limited formal scoring stakes wider influence over high-stakes selection.