Shu Hu

Australian National University · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Macroeconomics, Econometrics, Labor, Finance

Job market paper

Consumption and Wealth Tails in Heterogeneous-Agent Models: The Pareto Trap

Household wealth is much more concentrated at the top than household consumption. In Australia's HILDA and China's CHIPS, the estimated Pareto tail index for consumption exceeds that for wealth, consistent with existing U.S. evidence. We show that a model cannot reproduce this ranking if optimal consumption remains above a fixed positive fraction of wealth at all sufficiently high wealth levels. In the income-fluctuation models studied here, a stability condition used to establish a stationary Pareto wealth tail also implies this lower bound, producing a Pareto trap. We calibrate a standard model to benchmark wealth-tail indices while leaving consumption untargeted. In every calibration, the consumption-wealth ratio converges to a positive limit, so the model satisfies the lower bound condition. Separately, an asymptotic Pareto benchmark shows that replacing a consumption-tail index of 3.0 with a wealth-tail index of 1.5 raises the implied top 1% consumption share from 4.6% to 21.5%, a factor of about 4.6. Matching the wealth tail is therefore not sufficient for model validation: the same model also generates a testable, untargeted implication for the consumption tail.