Website CV Paper
Fields
Labor, Law & Crime, Public
Job market paper
Police Discretion and Pre-Arrest Diversion: Evidence from Florida
Misdemeanor offenses account for a large share of criminal justice contact, and even low-level encounters can have lasting consequences for defendants. This paper examines the causal effect of initial noncustodial police processing, rather than custodial arrest, on diversion access, case outcomes, and subsequent criminal justice contact. Using administrative data from Florida's Eighth Judicial Circuit, I study an adult pre-arrest diversion program administered by the State Attorney's Office, where police officers determine the initial processing route but do not directly decide diversion participation. To address the endogeneity of officers' decisions, I use an instrumental-variables design exploiting variation in officers' propensity to process eligible misdemeanor encounters noncustodially. The results show that initial noncustodial processing increases the probability of a pre-arrest diversion intake meeting by 40.3 percentage points and diversion entry by 33.3 percentage points. Although the estimates suggest a reduction in subsequent arrests within two years, the effects on subsequent criminal justice contact and index-case outcomes are not precisely estimated. Overall, the findings highlight the importance of police discretion at the earliest stage of the criminal justice process and demonstrate how initial police decisions can influence access to prosecutor-administered diversion programs.