Website CV Paper
Fields
Environmental & Energy, Industrial Organization
Job market paper
Cheap to Keep: Insurance Pricing and the Retirement of Hazardous Capital
Federal law requires every gas station in the United States to insure against leaks from its underground fuel tanks, the most frequently reported source of groundwater pollution. A tank's chance of leaking nearly doubles as it ages into its twenties, and single-walled steel tanks leak more than double-walled ones. Most states provide that coverage through public funds that charge every station the same premium whatever its risk. This paper asks whether pricing that risk changes what stations do with their tanks, and how it compares with subsidies and mandates. I study Texas's 1998 switch from a uniform state fund to risk-rated private insurance, comparing Texas tanks with tanks of the same construction and age in states that kept uniform pricing. Risk-based pricing raised the annual tank closure rate by 0.9 percentage points, 38 percent of the control-state rate. Tanks 21 years or older closed 1.7 points faster, more than twice the response of tanks 8 years or younger. Stations both replaced tanks and exited, and confirmed releases fell by 46 percent of the control rate. A dynamic model of a station's tank portfolio and entry ranks risk-based pricing, a replacement subsidy, and an age-based removal mandate on one welfare measure. Extending risk-based pricing to the fund states captures 45.8 percent of the welfare gain from a first-best premium that prices cleanup and health damages. The subsidy and mandate do worse than today's contracts. The clean energy transition will retire far larger stocks of hazardous capital, and pricing mandatory insurance on risk is an instrument regulators already hold.