Abena Darkwah

University of Calgary · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Environmental & Energy, Public

Job market paper

Electricity Offer Behavior and the Effectiveness of Carbon Policy

This paper examines the effectiveness of Canada's first greenhouse gas pricing policy, focusing on the role of benchmark design and electricity offer behavior in shaping emissions outcomes. Exploiting the transition from generator-specific to uniform emissions benchmarks, I document a decline in coal generation relative to gas generation following the reform. Using a structural dispatch model, I find that the uniform benchmark produces lower emissions than a revenue-equivalent generator-specific benchmark. However, this advantage is substantially reduced when observed above-cost electricity offer premiums are incorporated into the model. Reduced-form evidence further shows that elevated gas offer premiums among large firms are associated with a higher coal share and lower gas generation following the reform. Structural counterfactuals indicate that observed offer premiums reduce the simulated emissions advantage of the uniform benchmark by approximately 64%, primarily by shifting generation from gas toward coal. These findings highlight how electricity market structure and offer behavior can impede or slow the decarbonization of the electricity sector.