Website CV Paper
Fields
Development, Finance, Labor, Behavioral & Experimental
Job market paper
Are small businesses not interested in loans, priced out, or turned away? Experimental evidence from bank referrals in Pakistan
Registered small medium enterprises (SMEs) in low- and middle-income countries do not apply for bank loans, even when loans are partially guaranteed against default and advertise low interest rates. We investigate if low application submissions are exacerbated by information frictions on firms, bank credit rationing, or misalignment of organizational incentives by randomizing to firms: (1) information on SME lending schemes, (2) preparation for the first meeting with loan officers, and (3) referrals between SME loan officers. While over half the firms interacted with loan officers, only 4% submitted applications. Negotiations around interest rate and collateral ended the process for 63 to 90% of SME-loan officer pairs, dropoff happened before bank screening, and very few firms were denied. Firms given information on lending schemes were asked for 19% (2pp) more interest. Firms referred to loan officers with greater default-concerns were 88% more likely to be quoted high-interest and property-collateralized loans, which (i) did not increase screening efforts of default-concerned loan officers and (ii) potentially adversely selected the subset of firms willing to proceed. Our results suggest that loan officers are not incentivized to offer promotional loans over standard ones, and that the way default penalties are currently designed might be pushing offered interest rates to be higher than what the bank prefers.