Website CV Paper
Fields
Labor, Industrial Organization
Job market paper
Unions' Internal Networks and Spillovers: Evidence from Right-to-Work Laws in the US
We document US labor unions' expanding geographic scope and show how the resulting organizational networks propagate shocks across distant labor markets. Between 2001 and 2011, the number of states in which the average union local (branch) operated doubled from 1.5 to 3. A consequence of this spatial configuration is that shocks to unionized workers in one state will likely impose spillovers outside it if unions respond by reallocating resources across states. We show this mechanism at work in the context of state-level right-to-work (RTW) laws, which make it optional for workers covered by union contracts to pay dues. A model of a multistate union predicts spillovers whose sign depends on the relative strength of substitution and scale effects. We test for spillovers using variation in union exposure to five new RTW laws adopted between 2012 and 2017. The laws had negative direct effects in the adopting states and positive spillovers to nonadopting states; six years after an RTW law's passage, the average treated union represented 20 percent fewer bargaining units in the adopting states but had offset 35 percent of this loss in worker-level coverage by substituting toward nonadopting states—with more than half of this spillover affecting noncontiguous states. We find no effect on the price or quality of union services. New organizing explains 34 percent of the spillover; the rest is attributable to successful contract renegotiations for existing members. Despite this substitution, the affected unions saw a persistent decline in membership, revenues, and assets.