Rachel A. Bryant

University of Chicago · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Urban & Regional, International, Macroeconomics, Public

Job market paper

The Geography of the Local Service Multiplier

State and local governments spend over $20 billion a year on firm-specific subsidies, rationalized by the direct jobs these firms create and the indirect jobs their payroll supports. This paper studies, conditional on firm entry, the strength of the local service multiplier and how it depends on commuting and shopping networks in a city. Using employer-employee linked Census data, I find that about half of the entrant’s new employees were not previously attached to the city labor market. Whether these workers migrate, commute from elsewhere, or were previously unemployed determines how much of the entrant’s payroll becomes new local spending. I build a spatial equilibrium model across neighborhoods, calibrated to these rates of migration, commuting, and labor force participation, in which residents’ choices of where to shop determine where their income is spent. In the model, the service multiplier is smaller than most existing estimates. For firm entries of the same relative size, the multiplier is about 2.2 times as large at the 90th percentile as at the 10th. Aggregate characteristics of the local economy explain only a small share of this variation, and much of the rest reflects the commuting and shopping flows around the entrant’s specific location. Finally, I combine the model with a new dataset of subsidized firm entry events that records promised jobs, realized jobs, and the state and local portions of a subset of subsidy awards. In most events, the added residential property tax from the entry covers the local share of the award, and residents’ welfare gains exceed the award’s full cost, assuming the firm would not have entered otherwise. However, the same subsidy can deliver substantially different welfare gains at other locations in the same city.