Sofia Shchukina

University of Chicago · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Behavioral & Experimental, Public

Job market paper

Love at First Photo? How Platform Design Concentrates Romantic Interest on Dating Apps

Romantic interest on swipe-based dating apps (SBDAs) is highly concentrated. This can frustrate both popular users who feel overwhelmed by a glut of attention, and less popular users who feel dejected by a lack of it. Is the concentration of interest exacerbated by the platform design of dating apps? To study this, I design, build, and run my own experimental dating app, which closely resembles conventional SBDAs and allows participants to form real matches. Across three field experiments, over 1,000 participants use the app to make over 70,000 matching decisions. Using a novel two-stage design that isolates reactions to different profile components, I show that visual components (photos and height) drive the concentration of interest: users agree more about which profiles have appealing visuals than about text, and visuals receive almost three times as much weight as text in matching decisions. I then test the effects of two common design features - the emphasis on visual components in profiles, and limits on the number of profiles users can express interest in - on concentration. Simply reducing the salience of visuals on profiles increases the likelihood that users pay attention to profile text, but does not significantly affect the distribution of interest. Limiting the number of profiles that users can express interest in, which many SBDAs do as part of a freemium subscription model, amplifies concentration: users do not redirect interest toward less popular profiles who they might be more likely to match with, and the limit binds hardest on the least selective users, who more frequently express interest in less popular profiles at baseline. Together, these results show that salience-based design interventions do not significantly redistribute interest in digital matching markets, while caps on expressions of interest can concentrate it, with implications for the design of matching platforms and other markets that limit expressions of interest.