Michael McKelligott

Chicago Harris · Public Policy · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Applied Micro, Economic History, Health

Job market paper

When the Germ Went Viral: Household Infrastructure and the Rise of Modern Hygiene

The germ theory of disease was widely accepted by the 1890s, yet infectious diseases remained among the leading causes of death in U.S. cities decades later. I show that the modern understanding of person-to-person disease transmission and corresponding preventive hygiene guidance did not diffuse widely until the mid-1910s, immediately preceding (and vastly accelerated by) the influenza pandemic of 1918. Using detailed household expenditure data collected around pandemic onset, I document that households responded to the pandemic shock by consuming more goods associated with modern hygiene (e.g., soap) relative to goods associated with outdated prevention practices. Moreover, I find that post-pandemic hygiene expenditures were higher among households with indoor running water and related fixtures that reduced the cost of handwashing, despite no detectable gradient beforehand. To test whether these differences contributed to health, I combine a new city-level measure of household hygiene infrastructure access with cause-specific mortality for 86 U.S. cities from 1910–1937 and compare their mortality trajectories before and after the pandemic shock. I find that a 10 percentage point increase in baseline access is associated with a persistent 4–6 percent decline in respiratory disease mortality in the years following the pandemic. This gradient remains even among cities whose public water systems served the entire population, speaking to contemporary debates about the merits of private relative to shared water access. More broadly, these results show how the returns to new health knowledge can depend on earlier infrastructure investments that lower the cost of adoption.