Kendyl Guzman

Clemson University · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Education, Public, Labor

Job market paper

Negative Selection and Peer Effects in Indiana's Voucher Program

Since 2020, public spending on private school choice programs has doubled to $10 billion. As school choice expands rapidly in the nation, it is important to understand how these programs not only affect students who use these programs but also those left behind in public schools. In this paper, I document which students select into Indiana's private school voucher program and estimate the effect of voucher student exit on their classmates who are left behind in public schools. Contrary to school choice models, I find no evidence of positive selection into the voucher program. Instead, students with higher rates of past disciplinary infractions opt into the program. On their exit, students with disciplinary records cause 2.7 fewer in-school suspensions and 1.7 fewer out-of-school suspensions per 100 left-behind classmates. These effects are less salient where educators' monitoring costs appear to be lower (e.g. younger grades and smaller classes). In contrast, the exit of students who do not have past disciplinary infractions cause no change in their left-behind classmates. My results suggest student reallocation improves the peer quality of public schools, rather than worsens it, contrary to predictions from most school choice models.