Arslan Ali

Columbia University · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Theory

Job market paper

When Transparency Backfires: Expert Selection and Communication

Regulators often demand that experts such as credit rating agencies be transparent. Suppose transparency means that the expert’s evaluation method and its results are public. I show that this requirement can backfire when a biased principal, such as an asset issuer, chooses the expert. Under a transparency mandate, the principal can hire an expert who shares his interests and designs the evaluation to persuade a decision-maker. Absent transparency, such an expert’s claims are not credible, and the principal must turn to more neutral experts. I identify conditions under which any principal would hire an expert who fully reveals the state absent transparency. Mandating transparency can then only harm the decision-maker.