Jared Grogan

Columbia University · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Applied Micro, Labor, Industrial Organization

Job market paper

Piece by Piece, Hour by Hour: Wage-Setting, Productivity, and Turnover

The choice of compensation method is known to affect employees’ effort levels, their selection into employment, and their human capital accumulation. However, in settings with especially high turnover, the costs of replacing employees can become significant and affect firm production. We explore whether a change in compensation scheme that leaves mean wages unchanged can nevertheless affect productivity and turnover using a quasi-experimental staggered adoption of new pay for truck drivers at a large American motor carrier firm. We demonstrate that, when drivers’ mileage pay is augmented with hourly pay for non-driving tasks, they reduce driving hours by less than an hour while increasing on-duty time by one hour. While mean weekly wages do not significantly change, we observe a 6% decline in paid mileage and a 2335% reduction in the probability of quitting in a given week when drivers receive both mileage and hourly pay. We explore possible mechanisms for these results, such as changes in the volatility of pay, the average speed drivers travel, or the modification “formed habits” around their expectations of weekly pay.