Kamelia Stavreva

Columbia University · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Labor, Economic History, Applied Micro

Job market paper

Skin Tone and Racial Inequality in the US: Evidence from the 20th Century

Empirical work on racial inequality typically relies on a binary Black–white comparison, treating racial categories as uniform and masking meaningful variation in how individuals are treated within groups. Using newly collected WWII draft registration records containing information on skin tone for the near universe of men born between 1898–1929, linked to the 1940 Census, we document large intra-racial disparities by skin color. Black men with light skin earn about 37% more than their darker-skinned peers. This unconditional gap is economically significant—if all Black men earned what light-skinned Black men did, the Black–white earnings gap in 1940 would be roughly 18% smaller. We explore several mechanisms behind these disparities. Comparing brothers raised in the same household, family fixed effects eliminate essentially the entire education gap, yet darker-skinned brothers still earn about 10% less (9 log points), roughly a quarter of the unconditional gap in the sibling sample, pointing to a labor market penalty distinct from the categorical disadvantages tied to racial classification. We then consider the role of discriminatory institutions. While Jim Crow exposure depresses educational attainment for Black men overall, we find no differential impact by skin tone, consistent with the one-drop rule's uniform legal treatment. Finally, we follow men from 1940 to 1950 and find that among men in the same 1940 occupation, lighter-skinned men were more likely to move into skilled work. Exploiting WWII-driven variation in labor market tightness, we find that shocks that reduced Black–white inequality had no detectable differential effect by skin tone. Our results show that differences in outcomes by skin tone represent a distinct form of inequality, one that reflects both inherited disadvantage and discriminatory forces that sort Black men by color and appear to differ from those driving broader Black-white inequality.