Website CV Paper
Fields
Econometrics
Job market paper
Paying to Sharpen Identification: Optimal Probing of Coarse Data
Observations that are rounded, mismeasured, missing, or otherwise coarsened can often be probed through follow-up questions, remeasurement, or linkage across data sources. This paper develops a framework for selecting which observations to probe under a budget constraint. The value of probing is measured by the reduction in identified-set diameter. For scalar expectations, and for univariate distributions under Wasserstein-1 distance, identified-set diameter decomposes into additive observation-level contributions. This decomposition yields a simple optimal nonrandomised probing rule: probe observations in decreasing order of expected diameter reduction per unit cost until the budget is exhausted. In a counterfactual survey-design application based on Manski and Straub's (2000) analysis of worker expectations, targeting follow-up questions to the coarsest 25% of initially ambiguous responses captures 71% of the estimated identified-set diameter reduction attainable by questioning all respondents.