Website CV Paper
Fields
Behavioral & Experimental, Health
Job market paper
Facing Unequal Opportunities: Does Experience Shape Redistributive Preferences?
We study whether firsthand experience of unequal opportunity changes how people judge merit and redistribute income. In the main experiment, third-party spectators are randomly assigned to complete either an easy or a hard version of a real-effort task, then decide how to divide a bonus between two workers, one of whom faced each version. By holding the workers' circumstances fixed while varying spectators' own experience, the design isolates the causal effect of experiencing advantage versus disadvantage. Spectators who complete the hard task attribute performance more to unequal opportunity, view the initial allocation as less fair, and redistribute more toward the disadvantaged worker, even when doing so is personally costly. An extension compares one-sided experience with experiencing both tasks and with receiving comparable information through reports or statistics. Experiencing both sides produces the strongest redistributive response, while information alone has weaker effects. Redistributive preferences thus depend not only on what people know about unequal opportunities, but also on how they encounter them.