Ke Shi

ESSEC Business School · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Labor, Education, Behavioral & Experimental

Job market paper

Borders Within: Citizenship and the Paradox of Belonging for Turkish-Origin Youth

Birthright citizenship is intended to align legal membership with social inclusion. But how does it change immigrant youth's experience of belonging, and does it do so equally across origins? I study these questions by analyzing Germany's 2000 Nationality Act, which introduced jus soli birthright citizenship conditional on parental residence requirements and sharply increased the share of second-generation children who were German citizens from birth. Using data from a nationally representative survey of ninth-grade students, aged around 15, I compare the immigrant-native outcome gaps across birth cohorts right before and after the policy cutoff with a difference-in-differences design. Among Turkish-origin pupils, outsider feelings and perceived grading disadvantage increase relative to natives by 0.33 and 0.40 standard deviations, respectively. In the pre-reform birth cohort, Turkish-origin pupils report greater group- and personal-level disrespect but fewer outsider feelings at school and greater ease making friends than natives. Across the cutoff, these advantages erode without detectable improvement in either disrespect measure. Turkish-origin pupils also show no detectable increase in attendance at Germany's academic secondary school track. More favorable changes emerge among children of other origins on selected outcomes. Among second-generation immigrants, the change in Turkish-origin pupils' personal experience of origin-based disrespect, relative to other origins, is more adverse inside the academic track than outside it. This comparison is consistent with the paradox of integration, although it does not identify a causal effect of track attendance. I interpret these findings through a recognition gap: citizenship at birth can rightfully strengthen young people's claims to equal membership and expectations of equal treatment, while the social recognition accorded to their origin differs across origin groups and changes more slowly. A reform that narrows the legal distance to membership can therefore expose the social distance that remains.