Thomas Hughes

George Mason University · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Political Economy, Applied Micro, Theory

Job market paper

The Budget-Maximizing Peacemaker: The Success Paradox of Peace-Through-Strength Defense Policy

This paper develops a general theory of defense bureaucracies as budget-maximizing institutions whose internal incentives can distort their stated missions. While defense bureaus are tasked with preserving peace and security through the maintenance of military strength, their need to justify budgets and maintain relevance generates what this paper terms the Success Paradox: the bureaucratic pursuit of peace may create incentives to manufacture conflict to justify continued funding and to suppress real conflict that later erupts into prolonged and destructive wars. Therefore, defense policy is not necessarily the neutral pursuit of peace and security that it is stated to be. The analysis builds on Niskanen's model of bureaucratic behavior to explain how these incentives operate across institutional contexts. Historical and contemporary cases are analyzed to illustrate variation in how defense bureaus amplify or manufacture conflict, suppress genuine tensions, or are constrained by institutional conditions that prevent the Success Paradox from activating.