Website CV Paper
Fields
Finance, Behavioral & Experimental
Job market paper
Should She Stay or Should She Go? CEO Gender and the Performance-turnover Gradient
Is CEO turnover more sensitive to firm performance when the CEO is a woman? In a broad sample of US public firms, we find that female CEOs separate from their firms more often than male CEOs, and that their turnover is more than twice as sensitive to industry-adjusted stock returns. This gender gap in performance sensitivity survives matching on observable firm characteristics and restricting the sample to firms that have had both a male and a female CEO, and is concentrated at weak performance. The gap is not explained by selection, since women are no more likely than men to be appointed to observably distressed firms; by voluntary exits, since the gap holds among explicitly forced departures; or by Bayesian learning about ability, since the gap is no smaller when boards have observed the CEO longer, or hired one with a more informative track record. Instead, we document several facts consistent with gendered attribution of responsibility: on earnings calls analysts hold management more responsible for a missed quarter when the firm is female-led; after weak performance the broader C-suite tends to follow a male CEO out but stays when a woman leaves; the gender gap in gradients is specific to the CEO, the role ultimately held responsible for firm performance, and does not extend to CFOs and COOs; finally, the gap is largest in male-typed industries, where women are least representative of the typical leader. Together, these patterns identify the turnover margin as a channel that can erode women's representation at the top even after they reach it.