Marema Gaye

Harvard University · Health Policy (Economics) · 2026–27 job market

Job market paper

Mental Health Care After Clinicians Transition to Self-Pay: Evidence from Medicare

Clinicians are increasingly leaving health insurance networks and entering selfpay arrangements, but how does this transition impact their patients' insurer-billed health care? I study this question by assessing the effects of mental health clinicians who formally opt out of Medicare on their patients' Medicare-billed mental health care, using a novel dataset of clinician opt-out dates linked to claims from a 20% random sample of fee-for-service Medicare beneficiaries. I compare patients of opt-out clinicians with patients of observably similar clinicians who do not opt out of Medicare using a matched, stacked difference-in-differences design. Following opt-out, treated patients have 0.52 fewer Medicare-billed mental health visits per quarter relative to control patients, a difference equal to 18% of baseline billed visit volume. However, estimated differences in the volume of psychotropic medication fills are not statistically distinguishable from zero. Patients initiate new relationships around the transition with clinicians whose treatment capabilities resemble those of their opt-out clinician, and mental health care within those relationships increases after the clinician opts out. Psychotropic prescribing from previously seen mental health prescribers and established primary care providers also increases. However, increases in visits with other clinicians do not fully offset the decline in billed visits from the opt-out clinician. Acute-care use increases around the opt-out transition, but differential pretreatment movement warrants caution in interpreting those estimates.