Xuanyi Jin

University of Hong Kong · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Industrial Organization, International, Applied Micro

Job market paper

Protection versus Differentiation: Trademarks, Marketing, and Firm Performance

This paper examines the rationale for trademark adoption and its impact on firm performance. We emphasize two functions of trademarks: protection and differentiation. Protection prevents competitors from using identical or confusingly similar brand names and logos. Differentiation helps consumers distinguish the owner's brand from others. An industry equilibrium model with endogenous marketing and trademark adoption rationalizes three facts we document in the data. First, most firms never apply for a trademark, although the application cost is negligible. Second, a firm's marketing generates positive spillovers to competitors' sales. These spillovers are stronger among firms with similar names, and arise only from firms without a trademark. Third, following a firm's first trademark application, the return to its own marketing rises while the spillover it receives from competitors' marketing disappears. We estimate the model using Chinese manufacturing firm data from 1998 to 2007. Counterfactual exercises show that stronger trademark protection and greater market transparency have large distributional effects. Both policies stimulate trademark adoption and marketing investment, but they benefit only the largest firms. Smaller firms earn lower profits even after adopting trademarks, because wider adoption intensifies marketing competition and reduces the marketing spillovers they rely on.