Website CV Paper
Fields
Labor, Public, Econometrics
Job market paper
When to Broaden, When to Focus: Job Search and Market Tightness
Navigating the labor market is hard and many public employment services advise jobseekers. Yet little is known about how this advice changes where they search and their chances of finding a job. This paper investigates whether advice directing their search toward tight markets improves re-employment. I link Swiss unemployment records to clickstream data from the public job portal, which show where jobseekers search before they find a job. I exploit quasi-random assignment to caseworkers differing in their tendency to give such advice. The tendency is unrelated to other caseworker behaviors. Being assigned to a caseworker at the 90th rather than the 10th percentile of this tendency raises six-month job finding by 2.8%, without lowering job quality. Jobseekers from slack markets gain from mobility to tighter markets, while those from tight markets gain from focusing on their market, suggesting that not only advice that broadens search but also advice that focuses it can be beneficial. A back-of-the-envelope calculation indicates that the advice would still direct search toward tighter markets if all caseworkers gave it, suggesting scope for wider use.