Maike Schlosser

Universität Konstanz · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Education, Applied Micro, Behavioral & Experimental

Job market paper

From the Courtroom to the Classroom: Evidence of Biased Legal Decision-Making in Law School

Extensive research documents ethnicity- and gender-based disparities in judicial decision-making, a puzzling finding given legal professionals' rigorous training in evidence-based reasoning. Whether these disparities originate in professional practice or already exist during legal training remains unknown. We address this via a survey experiment with about 3,000 law students across 19 German universities. We randomly assign students to treatment or control versions of five criminal-law cases in which only the main subject's name is varied to signal ethnicity or gender. We find that subjects with ethnic-minority names receive significantly harsher, faster, and more confident evaluations than those with German-sounding names, while female subjects are evaluated more leniently than men; both patterns carry through to sentencing recommendations. Effect sizes vary by offense type, and students exhibit in-group biases. Critically, bias magnitude does not decline with training, indicating current legal education does not correct these disparities and curriculum reform may be needed.