Website CV Paper
Fields
Public, Labor, Behavioral & Experimental
Job market paper
What Limits Childcare Expansion? Evidence from Demand- and Supply-Side Subsidies
Governments can attempt to expand childcare by subsidizing parental demand or by subsidizing provider supply. Combining administrative data on the universe of childcare facilities, novel surveys, and event study designs, I study how both instruments impact childcare capacity and enrollment using two large-scale reforms in Poland: a start-up grant for providers followed by a universal childcare voucher for parents. The two reforms jointly expand aggregate capacity and enrollment, but their impacts show stark geographic heterogeneity: enrollment rises by 22 percent in rural areas versus 2 percent in cities. To show how local demand and supply constraints underlie this geographical heterogeneity and determine the effectiveness of each instrument, I develop a model featuring capacity constraints, fixed setup costs, and demand uncertainty. The demand-side voucher lowers fees, passing 59 percent of spending through to parents, yet larger fee reductions lead to higher enrollment gains only where spare capacity exists. In contrast, supply-side grants expand enrollment by funding new slots where spare capacity is limited. Both instruments mainly finance inframarginal use and entry in cities, where demand is largely saturated. These findings imply that demand-side subsidies are effective at filling spare capacity, whereas supply-side capacity and investment subsidies are important when demand uncertainty and high fixed costs deter provider entry.