Website CV Paper
Fields
Macroeconomics, Finance, Economic History
Job market paper
How Much Does Anticipation Matter for MPCs? Evidence from Seasonal Bonuses and Lottery Wins
We study how household consumption responds to two very different income changes: one fully anticipated and recurring, the other entirely unanticipated and one-off. Using bank account records for 250,000 Spanish households, we compare workers who receive contractually fixed seasonal bonuses every June and December with workers paid evenly through the year. MPCs out of these bonuses average 21 percent over three months; they decline with liquidity but remain substantial across most of the distribution of liquidity and income. MPCs out of lottery winnings in the same panel are 29 percent over three months, and for households who receive both, the two MPCs are indistinguishable. Anticipation therefore matters far less than standard theory predicts: spending responds to cash flows more than to news about lifetime resources. Standard models predict seasonal bonus MPCs far below lottery MPCs, and near zero for liquid households. Models with a large share of impatient, constrained households can bring the two MPCs together, but only by making too many households hand-to-mouth and leaving MPCs near zero for everyone else. A model in which households dislike running down their savings links consumption more closely to current income and makes MPCs largely insensitive to anticipation. It matches both MPCs, the hand-to-mouth share, and several other moments. If this mechanism, or something like it, is important, policies that change current income flows will move spending more than those acting on wealth or credit, even for households with ample liquidity.