Pol Simpson

London School of Economics · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Environmental & Energy

Job market paper

The Economic Incidence of Natural Disasters

Policymakers and researchers often view the costs of natural disasters as local to the areas they physically strike. However, we show that a disaster's economic incidence differs substantially from its physical footprint. We study Pakistan's large and unforeseen 2022 floods, using original panel surveys of 5,100 households, satellite flood maps and a recentered IV design based on a hydrological model. A 10th-to-90th percentile increase in flooding within 15 km of a home reduces real expenditure by 10%, and nearly two-thirds of this decline is due to flooding more than 5 km away. The same spatial pattern holds for men's wage employment, prices, asset sales and credit access. Commuting adjustments help explain how these spillovers arise. Holding surrounding flooding constant, more flooding within 5 km increases the likelihood of commuting further for work by 4 percentage points, while flooding 5–15 km away offsets that increase. This suggests that households rely on nearby markets to cope with local losses, but lose that option when flooding becomes widespread. We quantify the incidence of flooding in general equilibrium by building a spatial model of trade and commuting. The model implies that whilst 40% of locations experienced almost no flooding, welfare fell everywhere, and 73% of the loss was due to flooding elsewhere. Targeting aid on model-predicted losses rather than physical exposure achieves the same welfare at 18% lower cost. Thus, ignoring the divergence between incidence and physical exposure leads us to underestimate disaster costs and misallocate aid.