Website CV Paper
Fields
Education, Labor, Econometrics, Public
Job market paper
The Impact of Digital Portable Devices on Student Achievement: Evidence from Staggered Adoption in Dutch Primary Education
Digital portable devices, specifically tablets and laptops, have become ubiquitous in primary education. Therefore, understanding their impact on students' academic achievement is critical. By exploiting a staggered adoption design of digital devices across Dutch primary schools, we observe both short-run learning responses from annual monitoring tests and cumulative achievement from high-stakes exit tests, while accounting for the specific grade level at which exposure first occurs. We find that the timing of device introduction matters. The effects on the exit-test results reveal that late introduction is costly: students exposed only shortly before the end of primary school score 0.14-0.17 standard deviations lower on cumulative achievement. Earlier introduction attenuates this negative pattern but provides no robust evidence of positive exit-test gains. This interpretation is consistent with the effects of the introduction of digital devices on annual monitoring tests. In annual outcomes, lower-grade introduction is associated with more favorable learning responses in both reading comprehension and mathematics: Grade 2 students with two years of exposure score about 0.25 SD higher in reading comprehension and 0.23 SD higher in mathematics, relative to unexposed students in the same grade. For mathematics, we find positive patterns across grade levels, whereas the effects on reading comprehension are more sensitive to timing: negative effects are concentrated when devices are introduced in upper grades or during short exposure windows.