Guthrie Scoblic

University of Missouri · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Applied Micro, Law & Crime, Public, Health

Job market paper

The Effects of Citations in Lieu of Arrests: Evidence from Maryland

This paper examines the effect of replacing arrests with criminal citations on defendant outcomes and subsequent criminal charges. Using web-scraped Maryland court records, I implement a difference-in-discontinuities design that exploits a January 1, 2013 policy shock encouraging citations for low-level offenses. The policy increased the issuance of citations by 48.5% among citation-eligible defendants and 39.1% among citation-eligible first-time defendants. Reduced-form estimates show sizable decreases in pretrial detention for these groups, falling by 36.3% and 41.2%, respectively. Citation-eligible defendants are also 5.2% more likely to have their cases dismissed. However, reduced pretrial detention among eligible defendants is offset by increased pretrial detention among defendants charged with more serious offenses that are ineligible for citation, leaving aggregate pretrial detention unchanged. Finally, I find little evidence that the policy increased failure-to-appears or re-offending.