Jenny Newman-Wang

MIT · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Development, Behavioral & Experimental, Health

Job market paper

When Caring Backfires: Experimental Evidence from Family Caregiving in India

Concern for others can lead people to hide information about their own needs – potentially harming both themselves and others. We study this in the context of household decision-making around healthcare for older adults. We develop a model in which elders withhold information about health needs when they “worry” about being a burden: they care about their caregivers and believe caregivers would feel pressured to help. We test model predictions using two field experiments with N=1,175 elder-caregiver pairs in rural Tamil Nadu, India. In the first experiment, we randomize who in the household is informed about a check-up opportunity for the elder to test for intrahousehold information frictions. Directly informing caregivers about the check-up increases attendance by 30% (5.3 percentage points), relative to informing only the elder. The effect is entirely driven by households where the elder reports being worried about burden at baseline, whose attendance more than doubles. Direct measures of communication reveal that worried elders are less willing to share information about the check-up than non-worried elders and more sensitive to randomized reductions in caregiver costs, suggesting worried elders believe sharing information imposes costly pressure on caregivers. A second experiment shows that caregivers’ decisions to help are not sensitive to randomized observability treatments that vary pressure, suggesting elders overestimate the pressure imposed on caregivers. Our results imply that concern for others leads elders to forgo care that both elders and caregivers value – but a light-touch intervention to reduce information frictions in the family can help improve take-up of preventative care for older adults.