Website CV Paper
Fields
Development, Industrial Organization, Labor
Job market paper
Market Power and the Supply-Side of Cash Transfers: Experimental Evidence from Chile
This paper studies the impacts of a cash transfer program on local businesses. We conducted a two-stage RCT in a Chilean municipality, transferring funds to the poorest 1/3 of households. We transferred these funds through a novel digital wallet with restricted redemption, so that households could use the proceeds only at participating local retailers. We randomly encouraged local businesses to join the digital wallet platform, so they could sell to households using this new payment method. We also randomized the fraction of firms treated at the local-market level to measure the supply-side responses to these cash transfers under different levels of market saturation. Firms respond to local cash transfers, increasing prices by about 9% and reducing competitive monitoring. However, retailers facing more competitive markets attenuated their price increases: a 10pp increase in the fraction of substitute retailers reduces prices by 3.4%. These results suggest that limiting local market power may avoid unintended price effects in the context of cash transfer programs. Finally, we estimate a structural model describing the use of and competition for cash transfers, identified using the experimental variation and transaction-level microdata. We use these estimates to run counterfactual exercises that evaluate the impact of different program designs on prices and welfare. Our estimates suggest markups average about 13% and most of the benefits of competition are achieved with a 60% participation rate within the wallet ecosystem.