Roberto Caputo

Norwegian School of Economics · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Behavioral & Experimental

Job market paper

The Fairness of Hierarchies

Why do people accept large pay inequalities within firms? In an online experiment, impartial spectators from the US population divide the earnings of a team in which all workers exert the same effort, but one worker holds a pivotal position: without their task, the team produces nothing. I vary the size of this relative contribution advantage and and whether the pivotal task requires a general ability, so that the role is assigned at random, or a specific ability that only one worker has. I find that spectators reward the pivotal worker more than the average worker despite equal effort, and the accepted pay gap increases as the difference in productive contribution grows. The irreplaceability of the worker in the pivotal position do not substantially increase the reward given to them, strengthening the idea that the contribution, more than other other deservingness factors as effort and scarce ability, is a relevant element underlying the acceptance of large pay gaps inequalities.