Zheng Hou

Ohio State University · Agricultural, Environmental and Development Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Agricultural, Applied Micro, Behavioral & Experimental, Environmental & Energy

Job market paper

Participation Incentives and Hypothetical Bias: Evidence from Two Experiments

Hypothetical bias (HB) is a common concern in stated preference studies, where respondents often overstate their willingness to pay for attributes of interest. Past studies suggest that participation incentives may influence respondents’ behavior, but their effects on HB have not been systematically tested. We conduct two split-sample experiments in two online discrete choice experiment settings: an alligator-hide product study and a donation study. In each study, respondents are randomly assigned to one of three treatments: a hypothetical treatment without an incentive, a hypothetical treatment with a participation incentive, and a real-payment treatment in which respondents purchase or donate using the incentive amount provided while keeping any remaining balance. HB is measured by comparing willingness-to-pay estimates from the hypothetical treatments with those from the real-payment treatment. Our results show that participation incentives lead to behavioral changes, including higher opt-in rates and stronger perceptions of consequentiality. However, although HB persists across both contexts, offering a participation incentive in a hypothetical treatment does not produce statistically significant differences in HB.