Irfan Khan

Ohio State University · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Theory, Behavioral & Experimental

Job market paper

100 or 20 Shades of Gray: A Theory of Discretization

We study how finely decision makers categorize a continuous state space. A decision maker commits to a partition of the state space, balancing the accuracy gained from finer distinctions against their cognitive cost. For a broad class of cost functions, the optimal representation is discrete, and its granularity adjusts to stakes, costs, and their prior over states. We test these predictions in a perceptual matching task in which subjects map shades of gray onto a numerical scale. The data reveal a disconnect between precision and accuracy: environments that should induce finer categorization lead subjects to use the scale more granularly, without a corresponding gain in accuracy. Our structural model separates how finely subjects partition the scale from how reliably they apply that partition to understand this disconnect. Applying the framework to classroom double-auction sessions, we find that higher stakes, more experience, and a narrower range of recent prices are each associated with more granular pricing. Together, the results present categorization as an adaptive feature of decision making that organizes phenomena from rounding and left-digit bias to endogenous focal points.