Jhong-Yi Huang

Ohio State University · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Industrial Organization, Applied Micro

Job market paper

Dynamic Yardstick Competition: A Study of the Japanese Railway Industry

This study examines the investment and effort decisions of rail operators under yardstick regulation, a mechanism in which regulators assess local monopolies by comparing their performance against industry peers. While economic theory suggests that yardstick regulation can mitigate cost inefficiencies stemming from rate regulation, there is limited empirical evidence on how it affects firms’ cost performance through investment and effort. I address this question by developing and estimating a dynamic structural model using data from the Japanese railway industry. Counterfactual analysis shows that, relative to the first-best benchmark, traditional rate regulation increases the capital stock by 20%, reduces effort by 5.2%, and raises total costs by 3.1%. Introducing yardstick regulation eliminates 93% of the effort gap and 22% of the capital gap. As a result, it generates annual savings of about ¥9 billion in total costs across regulated operators. These findings suggest that regulators can reduce regulatory distortions and improve cost performance by introducing indirect competition among local monopolies.