Website CV Paper
Fields
Development, Education, Behavioral & Experimental, Political Economy
Job market paper
Backlash or Bonding: Effect of an Integration Policy in the Context of Affirmative Action
Do policies that promote cross-group connections expand access to economic opportunities and improve support for affirmative action? I examine this question in the context of caste integration at a highly selective public engineering institution in India, exploiting random assignment of first-year roommates. I combine original survey data from 2,267 students across two cohorts with administrative records on roommate assignments. I develop a model in which students allocate social time between bonding social capital, which provides support and promotes well-being, and bridging social capital, which expands access to economic opportunities. I show that expanding cross-group connections improves academic outcomes for lower-caste students but comes at the expense of within-group support for both groups. One year after assignment, lower-caste students in mixed-caste rooms have better grades but worse mental health, while upper-caste students have lower grades, relative to their counterparts in same-caste rooms. Lower-caste academic gains are consistent with transmission from higher-performing roommates, while upper-caste losses reflect reduced same-caste collaboration. Three years later, upper-caste students have 20% lower internship stipends, while lower-caste students are less likely to receive a summer internship offer. Initially, cross-caste contact increases both groups' support for affirmative action, with each becoming more supportive of the policy dimension that benefits the other group. By year three, however, upper-caste students assigned to mixed-caste rooms are less supportive of employment reservations. Taken together, cross-caste contact narrows academic gaps but entails different costs for both groups.