Jun Hyun Ji

University of Pittsburgh · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Theory

Job market paper

Preference over Choices

Bringing about the same outcome can earn praise, blame, or neither, depending on what was given up and at what cost. I develop a decision-theoretic model of these judgments, which underlie how people reward and punish one another. From an observer's ranking of another person's choices (outcome–menu pairs), I separate her valuation of outcomes from her praise or blame for choosing them. She compares his actual choice with the one she expects and credits him for the sacrifice she expects him to make. These expectations depend on what she thinks ought to be chosen and what she believes he values. Hence, the more difficult she believes doing the right thing is for him, the more she praises success and the less she blames failure. The model explains why observers who agree on what ought to be chosen can disagree about praise and blame. By deriving these judgments from an observer's preferences, the model clarifies the restrictions built into familiar measures of kindness in theories of reciprocity and accommodates judgments those measures exclude.