Joao Francisco Pugliese

Stanford University · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Development, Political Economy

Job market paper

Consumer Misperceptions and Redistribution in Financial Products: Evidence from Brazilian Consórcios

Financial innovations may expand access to credit, but also introduce complexity that leads to consumer losses and redistribution across consumers. We study consórcios, a group savings-and-credit product accounting for 25% of vehicle credit and 12% of housing credit in Brazil. Consumers pool monthly payments and receive funding through lotteries or bids, with bids allowing those with liquidity to obtain funding earlier at the expense of other participants. Using administrative data covering 59 million contracts and a survey of 1,296 consumers, we document four facts. First, 81% of contracts lose money relative to saving and borrowing in the market. Second, losses are regressive. Third, firms’ allocation decisions favor bidding, which can improve expected returns, while consumers waiting for lotteries face long waits and large expected losses. Fourth, consumers overestimate the chance of receiving funding early through lotteries. These findings challenge explanations of demand based on the commitment benefits of group savings products and suggest that misperceptions about allocation probabilities may help sustain regressive contract designs. Experimentally correcting lottery misperceptions increases liquidity-constrained consumers’ valuations of groups with more lotteries while also reducing their reported market take-up five weeks later.