Website CV Paper
Fields
Labor, Industrial Organization
Job market paper
The Leaky Pipeline: Retention, Performance, and Promotion Policies
Despite substantial progress toward labor market parity, women remain less likely than men to be promoted in many professions. This paper studies how firm promotion policies shape these gaps in large law firms, where women make up half of junior associates but only a third of new equity partners. Using new administrative panel data from a large U.S. law firm, we find that differences in associate retention to the promotion stage account for 31% of the gap, while differences in performance among retained associates, measured using total billable hours, account for the remaining 69%. The hours gap itself reflects gender differences in part-time work -- and particularly the persistence of part-time spells. Although individual promotions are not observed, we infer the promotion policy from aggregate promotion rates and find that a gender-neutral promotion policy can rationalize the data. We then estimate a dynamic labor supply model to match these empirical patterns and evaluate how alternative promotion policies would affect worker behavior, promotion gaps, and firm productivity. Several counterfactual promotion policies can substantially reduce the gap, but with different effects on firm productivity. Accounting for part-time schedules when measuring performance yields the most favorable tradeoff among the policies we consider, cutting the promotion gap in half with weakly positive productivity effects.