Sijia (Teresa) Zhang

Texas A&M University · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Behavioral & Experimental, Theory

Job market paper

Are Ambiguity Attitudes Transferable? A Test Using DOSE

We examine whether model-specific ambiguity-attitude parameters are stable across situations with varying ambiguity and can therefore support out-of-sample prediction. Under Source Theory, ambiguity attitudes are simply a transformation of first-order beliefs. The smooth ambiguity model and modified Hurwicz expected utility (HEU-B) additionally allow for confidence in these beliefs, i.e., second-order beliefs, which should make ambiguity attitudes more transferable. Approximating second-order beliefs in our benchmark experiment, we find initial support: estimated attitudes change substantially across situations under Source Theory but less so under the two alternatives. For a more complete test, the main experiment adapts Dynamically Optimized Sequential Experimentation (DOSE) to elicit second-order beliefs and ambiguity attitudes separately. We compare the models' out-of-sample predictions across situations. HEU-B outperforms the other two models, while the smooth ambiguity model does not outperform Source Theory. Thus, accounting for second-order beliefs does not by itself improve prediction; how the model incorporates them also matters.