Fantine Xiao

Tinbergen Institute · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Behavioral & Experimental, Labor

Job market paper

Telling You How I Would Feel: Emotional Communication and Ambiguity in Trust

This paper examines how the opportunity to communicate anticipated happiness or disappointment affects trust decisions, beliefs about others’ reciprocity, and ambiguity attitudes. In a preregistered experiment, 400 U.S.-based participants recruited through Prolific are randomly assigned to one of four conditions: no message, a message expressing anticipated happiness, a message expressing anticipated disappointment, or a choice between the two. I measure trust decisions in a modified trust game and use an incentivized belief-hedge method to distinguish beliefs, ambiguity aversion, and ambiguity-generated likelihood insensitivity. The main analysis includes 350 participants who pass both comprehension checks. I find no statistically significant effects on trust decisions. Relative to the no-message condition, choosing between the two messages increases expected returns and marginally reduces ambiguity aversion. When only the happiness message is available, expected returns increase marginally and neither measure of ambiguity attitudes changes significantly. When only the disappointment message is available, ambiguity-generated likelihood insensitivity falls, consistent with lower perceived ambiguity, while changes in expected returns and ambiguity aversion are statistically indistinguishable from zero. Taken together, the results provide suggestive evidence that opportunities to communicate anticipated emotions can change how people assess ambiguity about reciprocity.