Peter Courtney

Tinbergen Institute · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Development, Education, Economic History, Public

Job market paper

Making School-Set Assessments Comparable: How School Assessments Hide Learning Inequality

Assessment has been found to substantially improve learning when results can be compared between schools, yet in at most a quarter of countries are all primary school students tested comparably. I recover comparable learning outcomes, without a new test, from assessments that are incomparable because their difficulty varies between schools. Because students sit their secondary school's assessments soon after arriving, I can compare primary schools through students who share a secondary school, and secondary schools through students who share a primary school. Two-way fixed effects chain these comparisons from 1.2 million South African students into a scale of grades comparable between schools. I show that between 2018 and 2022, the gap between rich and poor schools halved on school-set grades but did not narrow on comparable grades. Re-ranked on comparable grades, about three-quarters of primary schools change learning quintile. Comparable grades explain up to 2.5 times more variation in national secondary leaving examination results than school-set grades do. Students sort into secondary schools on comparable grades, not school-set grades. Estimating the value added of secondary schools requires comparable grades on entry, which my method provides.