Harrison Chang

University of Toronto · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Labor, Economic History

Job market paper

Economic Depression and Unionization: Evidence from the Panic of 1873

Does economic depression stimulate unionization? I investigate the first major wave of union formation in U.S. history following the Panic of 1873 and the ensuing Long Depression (1873–1879). Using bank loan data and newly digitized wage data, I construct two new measures of local depression severity and find that unionization was more prevalent in hard-hit labor markets. Through the lens of a model of workers' unionization decisions, this result reflects the interplay of two opposing forces. A downturn can encourage unionization by reducing the value of incumbent non-union employment relative to workers' outside options, leaving a failed attempt to unionize and potential job loss less costly. Conversely, deteriorating reemployment prospects can discourage unionization by increasing the cost of a potential job loss. The empirical evidence is consistent with the depression strengthening workers' incentives to unionize. Heterogeneity analysis suggests the relationship between unionization and depression is even stronger in concentrated labor markets.