Website CV Paper
Fields
Environmental & Energy, Development, Behavioral & Experimental, Public
Job market paper
The Idle Margin: Why Everyday Conservation Goes Undone
Vehicle idling—leaving the engine running while stopped—poses a recurring conservation puzzle: for sufficiently long stops, switching off saves drivers money on fuel while reducing emissions, so private and social incentives point in the same direction. Why, then, do drivers persist in idling? In partnership with a leading telematics firm in Pakistan, I collect 10-second GPS data on ignition status, speed, and location from 6,621 private vehicles. The average vehicle idles for 27 minutes per observed day. At baseline, drivers hold widespread misperceptions about whether warming up an engine extends engine life and how long a stop must last before shutting off saves fuel or reduces environmental harm. I use a randomised additive design varying private information, social information, payments, and an in-car reminder technology. Private information reduces daily idling from stops longer than 30 seconds by 1.8 minutes, or 9% of the control mean, and the effect persists after treatment ends. Estimated benefits are 3.7 times programme costs over the eight-week intervention, with about half accruing directly to drivers through fuel savings. Adding either social information or payments produces no detectable additional reduction. By contrast, activating the reminder device increases idling by 1.0 minute, with the increase concentrated in long spells—a pattern consistent with procrastination. The results show that everyday conservation failures can persist even when private and social incentives align—and that interventions meant to correct them can backfire.