Carla Srebot

University of British Columbia · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Development, Labor

Job market paper

Sorting into (In)formality: Job Offers and Worker Preferences

When do formal job offers move workers out of informality? I study informal workers’ willingness to accept formal employment and the role of wages and working conditions in their acceptance decisions. I use labor inspections in Brazil that require employers to register informal workers, creating opportunities to formalize within existing worker–employer matches. Within six months of an inspection, new formal hires correspond to 78% of detected informal men and 68% of detected informal women. Take-up varies substantially across workplaces: women are more likely than men to formalize in female-dominated industries, while the opposite holds in male-dominated industries. To better understand take-up rates, I develop and estimate a choice model in which workers decide whether to accept a formal contract at their current employer or pursue an informal alternative. Firm-level estimates show that men and women respond similarly to wages but differ in their valuations of non-wage attributes, particularly flexibility and parental leave. A complementary survey experiment elicits workers’ decisions under a guaranteed formal offer. Most respondents accept, and preserving take-home pay raises acceptance from 61 to 79% while substantially narrowing the gender gap in acceptance. The contrast between high take-up under inspections and low same-employer formalization rates in the broader labor market suggests that persistent informality largely reflects limited formal opportunities rather than workers’ unwillingness to formalize. When formal offers arise, wage and non-wage contract terms and the value of the informal alternative shape acceptance decisions.