Website Paper
Fields
Macroeconomics, Econometrics
Job market paper
Between Weak and Contaminated: Identifying Monetary Policy Shocks with Imperfect Instruments
No available instrument for monetary policy shocks is both strong and clean. Orthogonalising high-frequency surprises on pre-announcement information makes them cleaner but weakens their first-stage strength, and that weakness magnifies any residual contamination. Instruments that cover the whole policy decision, rather than the narrow window around the announcement, are strong but exposed to other contamination. I group instruments built from the same construction into families, whose members share their contamination but differ in relevance. Demeaning within each family removes the shared contamination, and pooling across families strengthens the first stage. In U.S. data, the pooled instrument is much stronger than the orthogonalised surprise and identifies a gradual decline in output and prices and a widening of credit spreads.