Ratzanyel Rincón

University of British Columbia · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Labor, Econometrics

Job market paper

Suppressing Paper Unions: Evidence from the USMCA’s Labour Provisions in Mexico

We study the effects of a major labour reform induced by the U.S.–Mexico–Canada Trade Agreement (USMCA) on Mexico's union system, which aimed to improve workers' wages and working conditions by eliminating paper unions—unions that exist only on paper, do not represent workers, and allow firms to forestall real unionization. The reform required existing collective bargaining agreements (CBAs) to be legitimized by workers through secret-ballot votes and introduced stricter requirements for signing new CBAs. As a result, 78% of pre-reform CBAs were terminated, with few new CBAs created subsequently. We combine the universe of pre-reform CBAs with matched employer–employee and survey data and employ a matched difference-in-differences design to estimate the effects on union firms. We find that the reform had a null effect on average wages, but employment and the wage bill at union firms increased by 3.6% and 3.1%, respectively, by 2026. Profits at union establishments in manufacturing also increased by 5.4% following the reform. To rationalize these findings, we develop a model of optimal firm sorting in which the reform reduces firms' marginal labour costs by eliminating payments to paper unions and weakens the union threat by raising the cost of unionization for workers.