Joan Alegre

Universidad Carlos III de Madrid · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Econometrics, Applied Micro, Macroeconomics

Job market paper

Choosing What to Calibrate and What to Estimate in Structural Models

Structural models often fix (calibrate) some parameters and estimate the rest, but this calibration–estimation partition is usually chosen by convention. This paper treats that choice as an econometric partition-selection problem. For each admissible partition, we construct a scalar sensitivity statistic measuring the local response of a target object—such as a policy effect, welfare measure, impulse response, or treatment effect—to perturbations of the calibrated parameters. One rule selects the partition that minimizes this statistic and therefore minimizes worst-case local bias from calibration errors. A second rule minimizes worst-case mean squared error, balancing calibration bias and sampling variance at a specified miscalibration size. We first illustrate the decision problem in two canonical examples. We then apply it to the New Keynesian model of Nakamura and Steinsson (2018), where the partition choice has large implications for credibility: some partitions remain reliable under sizeable miscalibrations, whereas others generate large bias from small calibration errors. The sensitivity rule requires only local derivatives; the MSE rule also uses the joint moment covariance. Both avoid repeated re-estimation and apply to a broad class of structural models.