Website CV Paper
Fields
Labor, Public, Law & Crime
Job market paper
The Effects of Prosecution on Future Offending
In recent years, a prosecutor’s decision to reject a case rather than file charges has become highly contentious. Critics of rejection argue that it forgoes the deterrence and incapacitation that prosecution provides, while reform-minded prosecutors counter that contact with the criminal justice system can instead increase reoffending. Evidence on how prosecution affects reoffending, and on how these effects vary across types of cases, remains limited. Using newly linked administrative records and the quasi-random assignment of cases to intake prosecutors and grand juries in Dallas and Harris Counties, Texas, I estimate the causal effect of prosecution on reoffending for felony and misdemeanor cases on the margin of rejection. Filing charges more than doubles the six-month reoffending rate for felonies and raises it by nearly three-quarters for misdemeanors. For felonies, the cumulative effect fades as custody and supervision accumulate and is no longer significant after three years. For misdemeanors, which bring little custody, it grows to 13.5 percentage points, or 46 percent, within three years. Indictment by a grand jury, which comes later and keeps many more defendants in custody, lowers reoffending by more than 80 percent in the first months, but this reduction fades as the added custody ends. These patterns suggest that prosecution lowers reoffending only when it brings incarceration or supervision. Where it brings neither, the increase is proportionally largest for defendants without a prior charge, for whom filing creates a first record. Overall, I find no evidence that prosecuting marginal cases causes a lasting reduction in reoffending.