Jing Zhou

University of California, Santa Barbara · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Behavioral & Experimental, Finance, Theory

Job market paper

Two Faces of Complexity in Correlation Neglect

Optimal portfolios depend on the correlation among asset returns, yet evidence on whether people respond to it is mixed. I show that a key driver is the complexity of two distinct cognitive operations that forming a portfolio requires, mirroring the two-step structure of the expected-utility axioms: canceling common-return states, which are choice-irrelevant (Cancellation Complexity, CC), and evaluating the cross-state tradeoff that remains (Tradeoff Complexity, TC). In an experiment that varies each friction separately while holding the expected-utility prediction fixed, both amplify mis-response to correlation — participants over-diversify even when the hedging opportunity vanishes — but through different channels. TC shifts the optimum participants perceive: an evaluation cost distorts choice toward portfolios that are easier to compare. CC shrinks the utility differences among allocations while leaving the tradeoff unchanged, and so carries no such cost. Outside the lab, I find evidence from U.S. stock returns consistent with the TC channel: the behavioral component of the comovement premium rises with the TC of a stock’s return distribution relative to the market’s, with no detectable change in its rational component.