Alisher Batmanov

University of California, San Diego · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Behavioral & Experimental, Development, Theory

Job market paper

Fragile Learning From Others

Behavioral biases in decision-making are widespread and often persist despite experience and transparent feedback. This paper examines whether exposure to others' optimal decisions can correct initial misconceptions and facilitate learning in an environment where departures from the theoretical benchmark arise from neglecting an informative signal in a worker hiring task. Using a laboratory experiment, I show that such exposure substantially improves the quality of one's own decisions. The analysis of the underlying mechanisms shows that this improvement is not driven by indiscriminate imitation, as responses to exposure are asymmetric in the quality of observed choices, pointing instead to selective adoption of observed behavior. Adopting others' decisions selectively, however, need not reflect an understanding of why those decisions are optimal, so I further evaluate the transfer of these learning gains to a modified environment once exposure ends. The main result of the paper is that learning from others is fragile: the improvements do not survive a change in the environment's primitives, and the acquired gains from exposure dissipate entirely. Comparing these effects with those of explicit guidance further underscores the limits of social exposure as an effective policy tool. These findings highlight the dual role of observational learning: while it can enhance the incidence of optimal behavior, the improvements it generates often fail to generalize beyond the observed context.